Working with Complexity
Working with Complexity
What makes climate action so challenging?
Climate action is an example of a complex challenge. This work is unpredictable, non-linear, and there are no simple solutions. An approach that works in one place may not work the same way somewhere else. Also, efforts to mitigate or adapt to climate change can inadvertently create new challenges.
When dealing with these types of challenges, it helps to have a framework. The Cynefin Framework was developed by Dave Snowden to help people understand the context of a problem and choose an appropriate way to respond. The framework identifies four types of challenges:
- Simple (also known as Clear, or Obvious)
- Complicated
- Complex
- Chaotic
Here's a short video by Sue Borchardt (2021) that provides a overview of these different types of challenges.
How does this apply to climate action?
For simple and complicated climate challenges, we can rely on best practices and expert knowledge, but for complex challenges, this is not the case.| Type of Challenge | What it's like | Example | How to Respond |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simple (Obvious, Clear) | clear cause and effect | Switching to LED lighting to cut down on energy use | Follow best practices |
| Complicated | cause and effect exist but requires expertise | Designing a large solar plant to shift from fossil fuel use | Use experts and analysis |
| Complex | cause and effect unclear, patterns emerge over time | Helping farming communities adapt to shifting monsoon rains | Try, . . . observe, . . . adapt |
| Chaotic | No clear cause and effect, urgent | Dealing with the aftermath of a major flood | Act quickly to stabilize |
What are the unintended consequences?
The video mentions that when dealing with complex challenges, we need to be aware of the unintended consequences that may arise. Below are some examples of how climate change mitigation and adaptation efforts have already led to dire consequences for some people.
Use the teal sliders to explore each example below.
A city bans older diesel vehicles to cut pollution and emissions and improve air quality. Unfortunately, many auto-rickshaw drivers, delivery workers and small transport operators cannot afford newer, cleaner vehicles, so they lose their livelihoods.
Funded by carbon offset sales to companies abroad, a government protects its forests. This keeps trees standing, but forest-dwelling peoples are evicted from ancestral lands and offsets let polluters in rich countries keep emitting.
People around the world are buying electric cars, so countries expand lithium mining to supply EV batteries. This supports the shift away from fossil fuels. However, the mining drains scarce water that Indigenous farming and herding communities depend on, while the clean-transport benefits go mostly to wealthier consumers in other countries.
These examples show just how complex climate change mitigation and adaptation work is and how our efforts can cause unintended harms to others. So how do we move forward? Through collaboration, place-based solutions, and system transformation.